From: Tony Travis (ajt@doc.ic.ac.uk)
Date: 01/14/93


From: ajt@doc.ic.ac.uk (Tony Travis)
Subject: Re: HELP Linux in UK
Date: 15 Jan 1993 00:59:37 GMT

Athula Herath (athula@beta) wrote:
: [...]
: He may be refering to the problems in installing the SLS dowloaded from
: Imperial College. It can happen, depending on the state you are downloading.

I don't think so.

I've installed SLS 0.98p5 obtained from the tsx-11 mirror that Lee set
up in:

doc.ic.ac.uk:/pubic/computing/operating-systems/Linux/tsx-11.mit.edu

and the installation worked correctly. The only problem I encountered
was that the install.end files were compressed (so were renamed
install.end.Z) and the 0.99 kernel sources wouldn't fit on disk a4 along
wth 0.98p5 sources.

: IC (src.doc.ic.ac.uk) seem to mirror the archives of tsx-11.mit.edu
: (and funet). In the process when new files are added they are added to the
: archive without any significant time delay. But the mirroring process does
: not check for the file deletions.

You are quite right that, some time ago, we didn't have mirror deletes
enabled but I asked Lee to enable deletes because the old files were
redundant and confusing. Another problem was that some files in the
mirror were symbolic links pointing outside the area accessible by ftp.

I pulled SLS up to Aberdeen in the last couple of weeks and as far as I
can see the tsx-11 mirror at doc.ic.ac.uk is working correctly.

: The files in SLS disks changes from update to update (this happens very
: regularly). So if you download the SLS disks in between you are bound to
: have un-wanted duplicate files in some disks (say a3 directory may contain
: the left-overs of the previous version that has not been deleted by the
: mirroring process).

This is not true if mirror deletes are enabled is it?

: In fact this is a problem of any mirroring site (I checked at ftp.mcc.ac.uk
: which mirrors the funet (which in turn mirrors the tsx-11)) they have the
: same problem.

: If you are knowledgeble then you can delete the un-necessary files after
: downloading (best thing is to get the ls-LR from tsx-11 (tsx-11.mit.edu)
: and then determine which files goes to which directories, this is
: still faster than downloading the whole SLS series from tsx-11 as it is
: always over-loaded).

Yes, we are doing the mirror to avoid unneccessary duplication of ftp to
tsx-11 from UK sites. I couldn't work out what the extent of the overlap
was between funet and tsx-11 so we are mirroring both. These archives are
a genuine goldmine of Linux material and are accessible at several sites
in the UK including doc.ic.ac.uk

        Tony.